Direct answer
Yes. The New York Court of Appeals confirmed in Balbuena v. IDR Realty LLC (2006) that immigration status does not bar a personal injury lawsuit. Undocumented workers can recover for medical bills, pain and suffering, and lost wages, though future-wages calculations may consider immigration status as one factor.
In more detail
The right to sue for a personal injury in New York belongs to anyone harmed within the state. It does not depend on citizenship, a green card, a work permit, or any immigration document. The leading case on this question is Balbuena v. IDR Realty LLC, 6 N.Y.3d 338 (2006), where the New York Court of Appeals (the state's highest court) held that the federal Immigration Reform and Control Act does not preempt state-law personal injury claims. An undocumented construction worker injured at a job site in that case was permitted to recover for past and future lost wages.
Practical points matter.
For liability, your immigration status is generally not relevant. The driver who hit you, the building owner with a broken stair, the contractor who failed to install a safety harness, all owe you the same duty of care they owe any other person.
For damages, past medical bills, lost wages already incurred, and pain and suffering generally proceed without immigration status entering the picture. For future lost wages, defense attorneys may argue that a jury can consider the likelihood the plaintiff will remain in the United States, which can affect the wage rate used in the calculation. Strong cases address this with vocational experts and an honest record.
For construction injuries, the protections of NY Labor Law § 240 (the Scaffold Law) and NY Labor Law § 241 (specifically § 241(6)) apply to workers regardless of status. Balbuena explicitly involved a § 240 claim. If you fell from a scaffold, ladder, or other elevation-related hazard, those statutes are written to protect the worker, not to ask for papers.
Filing a lawsuit does not automatically notify ICE. Civil personal injury court records are public, but federal immigration enforcement is not built into the civil litigation process. The general three-year statute of limitations for personal injury under NY CPLR § 214(5) applies to undocumented and documented plaintiffs equally.
Many New York firms handle these cases in Spanish and other languages, and treat client confidentiality seriously. The constitutional right to access state courts does not depend on immigration status.
What I see in NYC cases
I represent undocumented clients regularly. The most common worry on the first call is "if I sue, will ICE find out." That fear keeps people from claims they have every right to pursue. The honest answer is that a civil case in state court does not trigger immigration enforcement. The bigger practical issue is documentation: pay stubs, W-2s, 1099s, or other records to support a lost-wage claim. Without papers some clients are paid in cash and have a harder time proving their pre-accident wage rate. We work around that with employer testimony, industry wage data, and contemporaneous records. The case still moves. The recovery is still real. Status does not change the duty the defendant owed.
Related questions
- What is New York Labor Law 240?
- What is the statute of limitations for personal injury in New York?
- How do I prove negligence in a New York personal injury case?
Talk to Nick
Call or text 718-261-0546. Spanish line available. Free consultation, contingency fee, no recovery no fee. Form on /contact.
Practice area pages: Construction & Labor Law 240, NYC Personal Injury Pillar, Contact.
Compliance
Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This page is general information about New York law and is not legal advice for any specific case. Consult an attorney about your facts before acting on anything you read here.