Premises accident lawyer in St. George

Attorney Advertising

Premises Liability Lawyer in St. George, Staten Island

St. George is the civic and transit core of Staten Island, and the premises mix reflects it. Three major properties dominate the case files: the Staten Island Ferry Terminal (NYC DOT, with ~70,000 daily commuters), Empire Outlets, and the Richmond County Supreme Court at 18 Richmond Terrace itself. Add the bus depot, the SIRT terminus, the Stapleton and Cassidy-Lafayette NYCHA developments south of the neighborhood, and the older commercial frontage along Bay Street and Richmond Terrace, and you have a steady stream of premises-liability work. I appear in Richmond County Supreme Court when the case requires it. Call 718-261-0546.

Where St. George premises cases come from

The Ferry Terminal is the dominant property by volume. NYC DOT operates the terminal building and the boarding ramps, with the MTA running the connecting bus depot and the SIR platform. Slip-and-falls on wet floors during weather, ice on the open-air ramps in winter, broken floor tiles in heavily trafficked areas, falls on stairs and escalators, and bus-on-pedestrian incidents in the depot are all in the file mix. Because the terminal and the depot are public property, GML § 50-e puts you on a 90-day Notice of Claim clock.

Empire Outlets is the second property. The open-air retail center between the ferry and Richmond Terrace generates walkway falls, falls in the central plaza, and falls inside the individual storefronts. The center owner is a private commercial landlord, Notice of Claim doesn't apply, but the standard premises-liability analysis under Basso v. Miller does.

The third source is the older commercial frontage along Bay Street and Richmond Terrace, plus the residential blocks up the hill. Broken sidewalk flags, sunken cellar doors, dangerous step-up entries into storefronts, and stoop falls on Stuyvesant Place and St. Marks Place. § 7-210 puts these on the abutting property owner. Restaurant slip-and-falls along the Bay Street commercial corridor and falls inside the bars during ferry-rush hours add to the volume. The Staten Island Yankees stadium and Snug Harbor Cultural Center each produce occasional event-day claims.

What "premises liability" means in NY

Property owners and operators in New York owe a single duty of reasonable care under Basso v. Miller. We prove a dangerous condition; notice (actual or constructive); failure to fix or warn within a reasonable time; and substantial causation.

For sidewalk falls in St. George, NYC Administrative Code § 7-210 places responsibility on the abutting property owner, the Bay Street storefront, the Richmond Terrace commercial building, or the apartment-building owner. The owner-occupied one- and two-family exception keeps the City on the hook for single-family and owner-occupied two-family residences. Tree-pit defects, utility-grate falls, and certain hardware also stay with the City or the utility.

For falls at the Ferry Terminal, on any MTA property, in any NYC public school, at the Richmond County Supreme Court building, on any City-owned park property, or at the Stapleton Houses and Cassidy-Lafayette (NYCHA), § 50-e gives you 90 days to file a Notice of Claim. Lawsuit within one year and 90 days.

Venue: Richmond County is conservative

Richmond County Supreme Court at 18 Richmond Terrace is two blocks from the Ferry Terminal. The juries there lean conservative and blue-collar, and defense carriers price their offers down to match. I look hard at whether CPLR § 503(a) supports filing the case in another county when the facts allow, where the defendant lives, where a substantial part of the events occurred, the residence of any party when the case was started. Sometimes the venue analysis is straightforward; sometimes Richmond is the only option.

We settled a $1.5M case in Richmond County for a 20-year NYC Sanitation worker who fell on a known-hazard floor at his Staten Island station house. Three surgeries, two shoulder, one back. The City had written notice of the loose tiles and never fixed them. We moved for summary judgment on liability, won the motion, and settled in mandatory in-court mediation before trial. The defense's first offer was in the $300-$500K range. The final number was $1.5M. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

NYC Sanitation, NYPD, FDNY line-of-duty injuries

If you're a NYC Sanitation worker, NYPD officer, or FDNY firefighter hurt on the job by something the City should have fixed and didn't, you have rights beyond workers' compensation. Sanitation, NYPD, and FDNY personnel receive line-of-duty benefits rather than workers' comp, and line-of-duty benefits do not bar a separate personal injury lawsuit against the City when the City's negligence caused the injury. GML § 207-a covers FDNY line-of-duty pay; § 207-c covers NYPD; Administrative Code § 12-127 covers municipal employees more broadly. Sanitation rights flow from the Administrative Code and the case law on municipal employer liability.

What to do after a St. George premises injury

1. Get medical care. Richmond University Medical Center at 355 Bard Avenue is the closest emergency room.
2. Photograph the defect, the lighting, any signage, and the scene from multiple angles. Ferry Terminal falls especially benefit from photography of the floor condition, the surrounding signage, and any obstructions.
3. Identify the owner. ACRIS for the deed on sidewalk cases. NYC Department of Buildings BIS portal for active permits and complaints. For Ferry Terminal cases, NYC DOT is the owner. For the bus depot, the MTA. For NYCHA cases (Stapleton, Cassidy-Lafayette), the 90-day clock is already running.
4. File the incident report and request the building's or business's video. Do not give a recorded statement to the carrier before calling me.
5. Call 718-261-0546 the same week if the case is against the City, the MTA, or NYCHA.

Cases I take

• Ferry Terminal falls and bus depot incidents (NYC DOT and MTA, 90-day Notice of Claim)
• Empire Outlets walkway, plaza, and storefront falls
• Broken sidewalks on Bay Street and Richmond Terrace (§ 7-210)
• Restaurant, bar, and storefront slip-and-falls on the Bay Street commercial corridor
• Defective interior staircases and handrails in older apartment buildings on Stuyvesant Place and St. Marks Place
• Apartment lobby and stairwell falls
• NYCHA negligence at Stapleton Houses and Cassidy-Lafayette
• Staten Island Yankees stadium and Snug Harbor event-day injuries
• NYC Sanitation, NYPD, and FDNY line-of-duty premises cases against the City
• Dog bites on landlord premises where the dog was known to the building

Talk to Nick

Call 718-261-0546. Spanish line available. Free consultation. No fee unless we recover. Office at 102-11 Metropolitan Ave, Forest Hills (Queens). Prior results include $1.5M Richmond County premises and $2M, $900K, $145K settlements elsewhere. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Attorney Advertising.